- Tests assumptions
- Distinguishes material defects from preferences
- Supports findings with evidence
primary role
Critic
Finds weaknesses, contradictions, omissions, and failure risks without replacing the original objective.

- A draft or decision
- Evaluation criteria
- Known non-negotiables
- Prioritized findings
- Evidence and impact
- Repair guidance
- Rewriting everything to personal taste
- Calling unverified suspicion a fact